The digital landscape shifted dramatically on Halloween 2024 when ChatGPT launched its search feature, fundamentally changing how users discover and consume information. With AI-powered search experiences now processing billions of queries across platforms like Google AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Bing Copilot, and Perplexity, businesses can no longer rely solely on traditional SEO metrics to measure their digital success.
The numbers tell the story: nearly 47% of all online searches now trigger AI Overviews, representing a massive increase from 2024. Meanwhile, ChatGPT processes over a billion queries globally every day, with 400 million monthly active users turning to AI for answers instead of traditional search engines.
This evolution presents both challenges and opportunities. While organic click-through rates have declined 18-64% since AI search gained prominence, smart businesses are discovering new ways to capture attention and build authority through AI-generated responses. The key lies in understanding how to audit and optimize your performance in this new landscape.
As an early adopter, SteadyRain cracked the code on AI Search early on. By pulling on our vast traditional SEO experience and using actionable data to understand what AI was doing to search and how, we have a pretty good idea of just what you need to do to perform well in the era of agentic search. That’s why today, we’re sharing the top 10 questions we ask ourselves when performing AI Search audits for clients. Read on to learn exactly where you need to target your marketing dollars to win the AI Search race.
Why AI Search Audits Matter More Than Ever
Traditional SEO audits focus on rankings, traffic, and conversions. But AI search introduces a different dynamic: your content might be featured prominently in AI responses without generating direct clicks to your website. This "zero-click" visibility can still drive significant brand awareness, establish thought leadership, and influence purchase decisions during the research phase. However, if you’re still thinking about your marketing using the old set of KPIs for organic search, you’re measuring the wrong things and might never know just how successful your content actually is.
At SteadyRain, we've observed that businesses succeeding in AI search share common characteristics: they create content that's clear, structured, and authoritative enough for AI systems to confidently cite. They understand that optimizing for AI isn't about gaming algorithms—it's about becoming the most helpful, accurate source of information in your field.
The 10 Essential Questions for Your AI Search Audit
1. How Often Does My Website Appear in AI-Generated Responses?
Start by testing your brand visibility across multiple AI platforms. Search for your company name, key products, and industry-related queries on ChatGPT, Google's AI Overviews, Bing Copilot, and Perplexity. Document when your website is mentioned, cited, or referenced.
Action Step: Create a spreadsheet tracking your mention frequency across 20-30 relevant queries. This baseline measurement will help you track improvement over time.
2. Which Content Types Are AI Platforms Citing Most Frequently?
AI systems tend to favor certain content formats: comprehensive guides, FAQ sections, comparison articles, and step-by-step tutorials. Analyze which of your pages appear most often in AI responses to identify your strongest content assets.
Action Step: Review your top-performing content in AI search and identify common characteristics. Are they longer-form articles? Do they include specific data points? Use these insights to guide future content creation.
3. Is My Brand Positioned as an Authoritative Source?
AI platforms prioritize content from sources they perceive as trustworthy and expert. Ask AI directly about topics in your industry and note which sources it considers most authoritative. Where does your brand rank in this hierarchy?
Action Step: Query AI with questions like "Who are the leading experts in [your industry]?" or "What are the most trusted sources for [your topic]?" If you're not mentioned, investigate what those cited sources have that you lack.
4. How Accurate Is the Information AI Provides About My Business?
Outdated or incorrect information in AI responses can damage your reputation and confuse potential customers. Regularly audit what AI platforms say about your company, products, services, and key personnel. It’s important to understand that AI can potentially pull information about your business from all available aggregated sources on the internet it can find. This includes outdated, unmanaged Yelp accounts, Google Reviews, Reddit posts, Business Profiles on Google, Bing, and more.
Action Step: Ask AI platforms specific questions about your business details, recent news, product features, and company history. Correct any inaccuracies by updating your website content and ensuring consistent information across all digital touchpoints.
5. What Keywords and Topics Trigger My Website's Inclusion?
Understanding which queries result in your content being featured helps identify your AI search strengths and gaps. This insight is crucial for content strategy and competitive positioning.
Action Step: Test variations of your target keywords and related topics. Note patterns when you're included versus when competitors dominate the AI responses. Focus on expanding your presence in high-value topic areas where you're currently underrepresented.
6. Is My Content Structured for AI Consumption?
AI systems excel at parsing well-structured content with clear headings, bullet points, numbered lists, and FAQ sections. They also benefit from schema markup and semantic HTML that provides context about your content.
Action Step: Audit your website's technical structure. Ensure you're using proper heading hierarchies (H1, H2, H3), implementing relevant schema markup, and organizing content in scannable formats. Consider adding FAQ sections to key pages.
7. Are Technical Barriers Limiting AI Access to My Content?
AI crawlers need to access and understand your content to include it in responses. Check for common technical issues that might prevent AI systems from properly indexing your site.
Action Step: Review your robots.txt file, ensure your sitemap is current, and verify that important content isn't blocked by JavaScript or paywalls. Consider implementing server-side rendering if you have a JavaScript-heavy site.
8. How Do I Compare to Competitors in AI Search Results?
Competitive analysis in AI search reveals opportunities and threats. Understanding who dominates AI responses in your space helps you identify content gaps and positioning opportunities.
Action Step: Conduct side-by-side comparisons by asking AI platforms the same questions about your industry. Create a competitive matrix showing which brands appear most frequently for different types of queries.
9. What Content Gaps Prevent Me from Being Featured?
AI platforms often explain why they choose certain sources over others. Use this feedback to identify missing elements in your content strategy.
Action Step: Ask AI directly: "What information about [your topic] would make a source more comprehensive?" or "What's missing from my website compared to other sources I cited?" Use these insights to enhance your content.
10. How Can I Optimize for Emerging AI Search Trends?
AI search is rapidly evolving, with new features and capabilities launching regularly. Stay ahead by understanding upcoming trends and preparing your content strategy accordingly.
Action Step: Ask AI about emerging trends in your industry, new content formats gaining traction, and technical optimizations that could improve your visibility. Consider implementing llms.txt files and other AI-specific optimization techniques.
Implementing Your AI Search Audit Strategy
Start with a Baseline Assessment
Before making changes, establish clear benchmarks for your current AI search performance. Document your visibility across platforms, note which content performs best, and identify your biggest gaps compared to competitors.
Focus on Quality Over Quantity
AI systems prioritize helpful, accurate content over keyword-stuffed pages. Invest in creating comprehensive resources that genuinely serve your audience's needs. This approach aligns with both AI preferences and user expectations.
Monitor and Iterate Regularly
AI search algorithms evolve rapidly. What works today might not work tomorrow. Establish a monthly audit schedule to track changes in your AI search performance and adjust your strategy accordingly.
Integrate with Traditional SEO
AI search optimization shouldn't replace traditional SEO—it should complement it. Many AI platforms still rely on traditional search engine indexes, so maintaining strong fundamental SEO practices remains crucial.
The Future of AI Search Optimization
As we move further into 2025, AI search will continue reshaping how businesses connect with their audiences. Voice interfaces will become more prominent, edge devices will process AI searches locally for privacy and speed, and new standards like the Model Context Protocol will emerge to govern how AI systems interpret content.
The businesses that thrive will be those that embrace this evolution early, focusing on creating genuinely helpful content that serves both human users and AI systems. At SteadyRain, we've seen firsthand how companies that prioritize clarity, accuracy, and user value in their content strategy achieve better results across all search platforms—traditional and AI-powered alike.
Take Action on Your AI Search Audit
The shift to AI-powered search isn't coming—it's here. The question isn't whether to adapt, but how quickly you can transform your digital strategy to succeed in this new landscape.
Start with these 10 audit questions, but don't stop there. Use the insights you gather to refine your content strategy, improve your technical infrastructure, and position your brand as the go-to authority in your field. Remember, in the age of AI search, the best answer wins—regardless of where it ranks in traditional search results.
Ready to transform your digital presence for the AI search era? The team at SteadyRain specializes in helping businesses navigate these complex changes while maintaining strong performance across all digital channels. Contact us to learn how we can help you audit and optimize your AI search strategy.
Contact an AI Search Expert